On Cloudrunner 3 Max vs Saucony Guide 19

Head-to-head on the manufacturers' published specs. Both are top picks in our "Best Stability Running Shoes (Flat Feet and Overpronation)" guide.

Pick the On Cloudrunner 3 Max if you want a higher cushioning score (10.0 vs 6.8); pick the Saucony Guide 19 if you want a higher speed score (4.6 vs 3.4).

On Cloudrunner 3 Max

330 g 8mm drop Stability Max cushioning

Choose it if:

  • It suits long runs and runners who want maximum protection
  • You want a higher cushioning score (10.0 vs 6.8)
  • You want a slightly higher stability score (10.0 vs 9.5)

Saucony Guide 19

275 g 6mm drop Stability High cushioning

Choose it if:

  • You want a higher speed score (4.6 vs 3.4)
  • You want a higher lightness score (4.5 vs 1.0)
  • You want the lighter shoe (275 g vs 330 g)
  • You want the lower brand list price ($150 vs $180)

Both suit: runners who overpronate or want extra support.

ColumnHub scores

Cloudrunner 3 MaxGuide 19
Cushioning
10.0
6.8
Speed
3.4
4.6
Stability
10.0
9.5
Lightness
1.0
4.5

Bold = a clear lead. Scores are calculated from published specs, not lab tests.

Key differences

Cloudrunner 3 MaxGuide 19
Weight (men's, or unisex)330 g275 g
Weight (as the brand lists it)330 g (men's); 275 g (women's)9.7oz (275g) (men's)
Heel-to-toe drop8mm6mm
CushioningMaxHigh
Cushioning (brand's words)Cushioning scale 5/5 (Low to Max)4/5 on Saucony's cushioning scale
Brand list price$180$150
See every spec side by side
Still deciding? Get picks matched to your game. Take the Running Shoe Finder

Specs from each manufacturer. As an Amazon Associate, ColumnHub earns from qualifying purchases.